.funkyblue { color:#0000AF; }

[Ascaloth] Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu (2009), Episode 24: Suzumiya Haruhi no Tameiki V

LagannGurren LagannDai GurrenArk Gurren LagannDaiginga Gurren Lagann!(2 votes, average: 5 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
Popularity: 7% [?]

A turn of the body, a glimpse of an armband with the words "Ultra Director" of it, and a face bearing a shit-eating grin, were the first real glimpses of the titular character of the 2006 hit series, Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu. It was the last moments of the pilot episode of the 2006 broadcast of the series, The Adventures of Mikuru Asahina Episode 00, taken just after the group soon to be known as the SOS Brigade have completed their in-house project for their school’s cultural festival. For the past month, the Sighs arc have covered the erstwhile unseen behind-the-scenes events of the production of the student amateur movie, and this week, the new material of the 2009 broadcast comes to an end as the wild and wacky events of the Sighs arc draws to a close with Sighs V.

Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu (2009), Episode 24: Suzumiya Haruhi no Tameiki V.

And the secret of Yuki’s ventriloquism scene is revealed; much like the infamous Mikuru Beam scene before it, it was no cinematic trick at all, but a fluke result of Haruhi’s imagination running away with her unconscious reality-warping powers. And not only does the cat actually end up talking for real, it comes with a dry wit and a pseudo-philosophical bent to rival Itsuki’s as part of the package as well.

You know the cast have cracked when they start philosophizing with a cat.

Though the dire situation arising from the spat between Kyon and Haruhi has been averted, this still leaves the tricky fact that Haruhi’s imagination is still continuing to fuel the strange phenomena that has been appearing since the start of the production. With the appearance of the talking cat being the tipping point, the situation may not be as unthinkable as the end of the world which was on the brink of happening the previous time, but it is dire enough that it may well have become necessary to intervene.

Though the question is; intervene how? As the source of all the strange phenomena apparently stems simply from Haruhi’s runaway imagination, the obvious solution is to rein that imagination in. Which is perhaps easier said than done; for although "it was all a dream" might be a sufficient solution, it’s so stale a trop that it seems unlikely that Haruhi would accept such a trite ending to her pet project, even as amateurish as the product is already turning out to be.

For our first song, we will be singing Fuwa Fuwa Time….

Where did these guys come from?

Oh, ho. So this is when Kyon obtained the discount coupon he cashed in at the yakisoba cafe in Live Alive.

Things seem to be going relatively smoothly on the surface within the SOS Brigade, but perhaps all is not as it seems. The existence of the three factions within the Brigade has long been common knowledge, but this is pretty much the first time we’re made aware of the possible conflicts between the three factions, behind the eyes of the center of their universe, Haruhi, as well as the closest satellite in orbit to that center, none other than Kyon himself. Whose philosophy is the right one? Was the world really created three years ago by Haruhi herself, or has it always existed in this state since whatever beginning it might have had, immeasurable billions of years ago? Either way, what implications does this have for the very existence of the conflicting factions as personified by the three extraordinary members of the Brigade?

And, this is but only the viewpoints we have heard from the three sides, as heard through Kyon’s perspective himself. What guarantee is there that any of them, if there is even one among the three that qualifies that is, are telling the truth? The Time Travellers say they believe that the world has always been this way, and Haruhi is but an anomaly in the timestream; who can confirm that their mouthpiece Mikuru truly does believe that, or if she’s lying outright, or even if she has any real knowledge about her faction’s true beliefs and motivations?

The mysterious Organization initially stated their majority belief as being that Haruhi is a Goddess who created the world, and all its attendant curiosities (such as themselves) a mere three years ago; but if Itsuki’s contradiction a mere several months later is any indication, how do we know they’re stating the truth as they know it either, and how much or little do they really know about the situation anyway?

If any faction is closest to the truth of this particular universe, one might think the intelligent data lifeform known as the Integrated Data Sentient Entity would be it; yet, as their TFI terminal Yuki honestly stated; their "self-evolution" theory is what they say they believe in, but how can we confirm for certain the truth in their statements when in all likelihood, we humans probably can’t even begin to comprehend the Cthulhu-ian perspective of these aliens? And if we can’t even begin to comprehend, how are we even to start sifting out whatever ulterior motivations that the IDSE may have?

Pew pew pew

Haruhi has always had a track record of somehow missing the very things she’s looking for right under her nose due to her "common sense", but it strikes me that throughout the Sighs arc, Haruhi is either absent, conveniently distracted, or even entirely oblivious whenever one of the numerous strange phenomena happens, even if she’s supposedly the cause of them all. It’s not as if the SOS Brigade have the ability to go out of their way to keep everything a secret from Haruhi after all, which makes one wonder; is Haruhi really just so unlucky in a queer way as to never seem to find what she’s looking for, or is there an external force out there which is preventing her from realizing something’s up? Yuki mentioned that the external force is "us" as in the other members of the SOS Brigade, but clearly there’s only so much Kyon and Co. could do; are there hidden resources in play on the part of the three faction representatives, or is it something else altogether?

It also strikes me how three times in a row, each time Haruhi sticks a contact into Mikuru, the latter somehow ends up almost ending Kyon right there and then if not for either Yuki, or plain blind luck. If all the strange phenomena, the variants of the Mikuru Beam included, are the result of Haruhi’s runaway imagination, what does that suggest about Haruhi’s subconscious perception of Mikuru?

Om nom nom nom

Well, I suppose there’s probably at least one good use for Haruhi’s imagination-supercharged reality-warping powers. Perhaps Kyon could have "suggested" that she bring back other extinct species, like the dodo, the Tasmanian wolf, and such. Maybe she can even be provoked to bring back the dinosaurs….who would probably prompty proceed to rampage through all of human civilization. Erm….yeah. Scratch that last idea.

Dude, you look like a host who’s had a tough time with a lady customer tonight.

Fine details and subplot don’t matter? The ending not even confirmed? Perhaps even leaving stories incomplete? Hmmm….there’s been some talk about Haruhi being perfect for the position of Sunrise Director recently, but I don’t think that’s quite the case, although she’s certainly almost there. She just lacks one final ingredient; if only she’ll throw Kyon into the movie as well to engender some unwarranted homoeroticism for the fangirls, she’ll be all set. ;)

It’s very telling that whenever Itsuki talks of Haruhi in some sort of positive light or glowing term, he almost immediately gets a dark look from Kyon, and is forced to backtrack or recover. Normally I’d say it’s just a one-time fluke, but the fact that this happened 15,532 times before in Endless Eight makes me think this might not be quite the case. Perhaps, Itsuki isn’t just following Haruhi around with a smiling face simply because he’s just playing a role?

Continuing on from the train of thought about the three factions revolving around Suzumiya Haruhi, what kind of conflictory relationship do the three factions really have in relation to each other, as well as to Haruhi? What does it mean that the Time Travellers saw fit to warn Kyon, our window perspective into this world, about the duplicity of the Organization, and in turn, the Organization saw fit to respond in likewise by informing Kyon about the nature of the "honey trap" laid out for him by the Time Travellers? Assuming that both accusations are true, what does it say about the motives of both factions that they saw fit to attempt to sabotage each other in their efforts to get Kyon’s ear? More tellingly, what does it say about themselves that they saw fit to resort to such tactics to begin with? And not to forget, where does the IDSE lie in all this? Are they really just bystanding observers, watching as the other factions having a go at each other behind the scenes? Or are they even more active than they appear, their manipulations actually even more insidious than mere duplicity and honey-trapping?

Whatever the case may be, it’s very telling that even the usually unflappable, flawlessly FABULOUS Itsuki can actually be brought to a point where he would drop the facade just a little, and show his true fatigue at the cloak-and-dagger stuff pervading the secret part of the double life he’s leading. It just makes you think, who are these people? The only thing that can be said about them in common is; they all have the goal at least of maintaining the status quo around their common point of interest, Suzumiya Haruhi. That is what they’ll all work towards, at least.

With that said, the endless task of maintaining the status quo revolves at the moment around the question of; how to make Haruhi accept that her fictional world and reality are separate, and thus put at end to the strange phenomena her over-active imagination is causing? From the looks of things, they have finally managed to finish the filming while achieving exactly just that, so we’ll see in a moment just how they accomplished it.


But it isn’t Haruhi without mysteries, and to draw an entire Sighs arc full of mysteries to a close, we are left with one last mystery; if Kyon fell asleep, who was the one who finished editing the movie, even if it was with the most cheapo of visual effects? Yuki’s epic h4x does indeed seem to be the most likely candidate, but one can’t really rule out the possibility that it’s just one last hurrah from Haruhi’s imaginative subconscious, the very same source of all the hilarity which has been ensuing for the past 4 episodes.

And the answer to what seemed like an increasingly dire situation; the utterly mundane solution of having the Ultra Director narrate the standard disclaimer of all fictional film works. Sometimes, I think the Haruhi franchise is really a showcase of how the most mundane things have a profound psychological impact on all of us, even if it’s nigh invisible most of the time. Perhaps the Haruhiverse is but the titular character’s materialization of what we really all have; a rich inner world where anything and indeed everything can happen?

And with Sighs at an end, we are brought back to the time just after the last moments of the Melancholy arc, where it was only Kyon and Haruhi alone on that particular outing, and also where Kyon tried to out the true identities of the other Brigade members to the Chief. In vain, of course, for such a ridiculous notion couldn’t pass even the warped common sense of the girl known as Suzumiya Haruhi, who still believes she’s stuck in a mundane, uninteresting world despite her desire for something more, a lot more. However, it does explain why Yuki, Mikuru and Itsuki eventually got tagged with the suspiciously apt roles in the movie project much later on, and why Kyon was wondering whether such a coincidence was his fault.

And with that, the new material of the 2009 broadcast is at an end, with the showcase being Bamboo Leaf Rhapsody, the Sighs arc, and not least of all, the infamous Endless Eight. How was it all at the very end, though perhaps 4 more episodes remain until the broadcast actually ends for real? The 2006 pilot broadcast was a ground-breaking hit that truly set a standard back in the day, and indeed, it would always be a tall order if even possible for any sequel to really come within reach of that sky-high bar. In that respect, the 2009 broadcast was probably not even trying to do the impossible; instead, it was a filling in of what holes the 2006 broadcast had with the erstwhile missing context material, as well as perhaps simply having a little fun of their own, as evidenced by Endless Eight.

Was this new broadcast a failure? Many might say that, but somehow I don’t really think so. Is it a success? Not to the extend of its first iteration, that’s for sure. Was Endless Eight a fiasco? Perhaps to many, but I saw the humour in it all the same even if it tested even my patience. Could it have been better? Perhaps. Will there ever be a Disappearance? Who knows, but I think it’s quite probably it will come….in the form of a movie. It would work well in that format after all, plus it will get KyoAni out of having to animate such material as Intrigues and Snow Mountain Syndrome until, say, 3 years later.

But ultimately, did I have fun? Oh yeah; with the old episodes, with the new material, even with Endless Eight. In the end, it’s still Haruhi, with all the fun and the headaches that come along with it. And you know, I’ll settle for that just fine. And really, that’s all that matters.

やれやtれ。 Ascaloth of RIUVA, signing out!

Popularity: 7% [?]

Click now to visit J-List!

6 Responses to “[Ascaloth] Suzumiya Haruhi no Yuutsu (2009), Episode 24: Suzumiya Haruhi no Tameiki V”  

  1. 1 risingstar3110 6 comments

    Good works ^^

    Such a fun series and i want more, but i actually feel quite fulfill by the end of this episode.
    I don’t know how long will it be till the next season, but i knows that in my mind, the Haruhi’s franchise won’t find a fit competitor for many years to come (Higurashi was a close one except the animators and directors really failed to transfer the spirit. Only plot-based is not enough)

  2. 2 Triple_R 3 comments

    Nice review, and lovely screen shot selection! I particularly liked your thoughts on the the different perspectives offered up by Itsuki, Mikuru, and yuki, and your questioning of how Haruhi keeps conveniently missing all of the supernatural events that she desires to see. So convenient, in fact, that this alone takes on a bit of a comedic feeling, as well. Perhaps Haruhi doesn’t want to truly find what she’s looking for, and rather she’s more interested in the journey to discover the extraordinary and the phenomenal, rather than the arrival at the discovery thereof?

    That could make for some interesting food for thought.

  3. 3 Tremere 28 comments

    It was a date still and Kyon should be happy about it.

  4. 4 mind author 1 comment

    very nice review..

  5. 5 Hypernova 22 comments

    Just want to give you a (pointless?) “nice post!” I enjoy reading your though in your style. And of course, I, too, like the show even though it could have been better (what couldn’t anyway?)

  6. 6 teohhanhui 10 comments

    That was a really nice episode!! ^^

Do not use any < and > for your own sake. It will end the comment there and then. Also, there is an automatic IQ filter which weeds out comments made by those who accidentally got transported from the stone age.

Leave a Reply

What would you like to see more of here?
  • Scathing reviews.: 18% (433)
  • Funny lists.: 13% (301)
  • Sexy pictures.: 54% (1305)
  • Event coverage.: 2% (58)
  • Interviews.: 2% (52)
  • Photos.: 11% (253)

Total Votes : 2402

Featured Feeds

Most Commented Posts


  • 10 currently online
  • 71 maximum concurrent
  • 4125208 total visitors

E2046 - The GK e-Shop